Tuesday, December 17, 2013

Cookie Exchance "Thumprint" Cookies

Tonight is my first (hopefully annual) Cookie Exchange with my friends to celebrate my birthday.  I decided to make cookies I've been making for years, literally, I learned how to make them in pre-school.  They are so simple and easy (same as everything I make) and only have FOUR ingredients.

Thumprint Cookie Recipe
1 cup bisquick
1/4 cup oil
1 egg
1 package instant chocolate pudding
(makes about 15 cookies)
I usually (at least) double the recipe
Baking Instructions:
- Roll in ball and press thumb in center
- Put candy in the indentation
- For more cookies double (does not make a lot)
- Bake at 350 degrees for 5-10 minutes (depending on how big your roll the ball)

Total preparation, baking, and cleaning up time is less than one hour!!

You can make these for any holiday or event by switching up the color of the m&m's! They are also great for Valentine's Day, Fourth of July & Halloween.
Xo C


  1. Yum! I love how versatile they are for multiple occasions! Thanks for joining in!

  2. Thanks for joining us! These look great!

  3. Wow! Those are so cute and festive! I've never made cookies with Bisquick and pudding...I'm intrigued. :) I love recipes with only a few ingredients. Thanks for sharing!

    Whitney @ Come Home For Comfort